Skip to content

How Asset Managers Win the Second Meeting

You walk out of a first meeting sure it went well. The conversation flowed, the allocator nodded along, and you covered everything on your agenda.

Then the second meeting never gets booked.

If you lead distribution, sales, or marketing at an asset management firm, you know how often this happens. Boutique and specialist managers sell to allocators, consultants, and the advisors who build portfolios, and every one of those relationships depends on a second meeting. Whether you run a founder-led boutique or a wholesaler desk at a larger manager, the first meeting sets the terms for the whole relationship that follows.

I talked with Stacy Havener, founder and CEO of Havener Capital Partners, who has raised more than $8 billion for new and undiscovered funds, about the approach she calls Ditch the Pitch. “You may have thought the meeting went great,” says Stacy, “but they [the allocator] didn’t.” Nailing the second meeting takes three steps: start with a story, ditch the pitch, and measure what matters.

Step 1: Start with a story

Every second meeting begins with a story that explains who your firm is and why it exists. “If the story is weak and your differentiators sound like everybody else, it will not resonate,” says Stacy. “It’s too crowded.”

For firms moving from founders to a second generation, this means telling the story in order: back to the founding philosophy, through today, and forward, with the current leaders carrying the founder’s thread. Personalizing the story for the person sitting across from you is crucial, and Pre-Meeting Prep in Jump pulls an allocator’s profile, relationship history, and product interest into one view so you can tailor your story before you walk in.

Step 2: Ditch the pitch

The purpose of a first meeting is to earn the next one, so the prospect should actually get the first and longest turn to talk. It’s a pretty common mistake, Stacy explains, for asset managers to make themselves the hero of the story. “The problem is that the actual hero of this story is not us. It’s them.”

Stacy cites behavioral science research showing prospects rate a meeting as great when they do about 70% of the talking, and she coaches clients to invite the prospect to go first and aim for an even split.

At a billion-dollar firm, a senior salesperson who asked an existing allocator to share their story over lunch left with additional allocations and introductions to two other teams. To build that habit, it helps to have a tool that tracks the balance when your memory can’t. Jump, for example, shows your talk time next to the prospect’s after every meeting, so you can see how the conversation is divided and apply what you learn to the next one.

Step 3: Measure what matters

You can track activity with metrics like meetings booked or fact sheets sent, but predicting the likelihood of a second meeting comes down to prospect behavior and signals. Stacy looks for unsolicited requests for information, replies within 24 hours, questions asked in the meeting, and questions asked twice.

Before AI, her team manually scored every deal on a custom Behavioral Quotient field in their CRM. Now, she uses AI to capture these signals during the call, which both helps her focus and reduces the admin time that would usually follow. These signals show distribution teams which prospects are moving and give them a specific reason to follow up.

“My least favorite email on the planet,” says Stacy, is the one with the subject line “Checking in.” A generic follow-up like that gives the prospect nothing to respond to and makes them less likely to move forward. Wholesalers and distribution leaders at asset management firms use Jump to capture the questions, product interest, and next steps from every meeting, so each follow-up builds on what the prospect said. Jump syncs that detail to Salesforce and uses custom Scorecards to measure each meeting against your own framework.

How to turn more first meetings into second meetings

Start with a story built around the person you’re meeting, give that person the first and longest turn, and use AI to track the signals they send back. Jump supports each of these steps for asset management teams with Pre-Meeting Prep, notes that sync straight to the CRM, Scorecards, Coaching, and Insights into how products and themes come up across every conversation. Jump helps teams save at least 10 hours a week, and distribution leaders see how every meeting is going rather than relying on gut feel.

Watch the full conversation with Stacy Havener here.

To learn more about how asset management teams use Jump, check out these resources: